Showing posts with label inkjet paper tests. Show all posts
Showing posts with label inkjet paper tests. Show all posts

Monday, March 30, 2020

Review--Hahnemuehle Bamboo Fine Art Inkjet Paper 290 gsm

An exciting aspect of digital inkjet printing is the wide range of paper surfaces available, an important element of the print’s expression. Now, a new concept in paper composition, surface and “look” has become available—Hahnemuehle’s Bamboo 290gsm, part of the company’s “Natural” lineup.
Photo: Courtesy Hahnemuehle: The Hahnemuehle Natural Lineup includes Bamboo, the subject of this review, and Agave and Hemp made papers. The other papers in the lineup will be reviewed in a future posting.

There are two aspects to the Natural line that make them intriguing: one is the sustainable manufacturing process. All the materials that supply the cellulose in these papers are made from raw materials that require minimal maintenance, grow quickly and do not need any pesticides. The other is their unique look and feel. This review covers Hahnemuehle’s Bamboo paper, dubbed by the company to be ideal for “spiritual” black and white and color images. In addition, the paper is made with no OBAs (optical brightening agents) and has “certified archivability”—their phrase, not mine.

Paper Surface and Rendition
Bamboo is a natural white, warm tone paper with a lightly textured, almost buff surface that I found to be an interesting choice for warm tone and certain other monochrome images. The paper is somewhat warm, but not brown/yellow, although when a blank sheet is held next to a bright white paper the differences become apparent.  In my tests it also performed well with color, albeit those that lend themselves to a low-saturation rendition. In terms of monochrome, it gave me impressive results from a series of images made with an IR (infrared) altered digital camera, probably the most expressive prints from those images I have ever made. Perhaps as important, it engenders a search for other images that would benefit from its unique look and feel.
My first instinct for testing was a group of images made with an IR-converted DSLR. This photo was made in The Everglades, and the paper match was just right and resulted in the most expressive prints I have ever made from this set. Copyright George Schaub.

Test Procedure
I did my tests using a Canon Pro-1000 printer and processed via Photoshop. I first downloaded the ICC profile from the Hanhnemuehle web site (www.hahnemuehle.com) and added it to my Color Sync profiles on my Mac. I printed using the dedicated profile in Photoshop managed color as well as printer managed (with black and white checked in the dialog box for monochromes), choosing heavy weight matte as the media. Both worked with matte black ink. The fairly heavy weight (290 gsm) requires a single sheet rear loading procedure with this Canon and other similar level desktop printers.

This is a single-sided (coated) paper, so it’s important to determine the printable side, as the slight texture can make it difficult at first to tell front from back. You can feel the difference by running your fingertip along the surface to feel the grain, which is slight in this paper. I could also see a distinct difference in the surfaces when angling the paper back and forth under a strong light. The company literature advises, if need be, to get a sense of front from back by slightly wetting your finger to feel the more “resistant” grain, although I hesitated to do this, fearing I would harm the print surface, but if you do this be sure to do so along an edge.

The company also advises that you might get a slight coating loss onto the print transport after running numerous prints, and suggests that you run one or a few (uncoated) standard sheets through to clear the transport, which should handle any problems. (Note: I did not notice any problems in that regard after going through 25 sheets of 13x19” paper.)

Print Controls and Options
As mentioned, I ran some tests using both printer and Photoshop managed color, the former using “heavyweight Fine Art matte” and the latter using the downloaded profile. Side-by-side I noticed slight differences in the darker values, with the profiled print showing slightly more open values, but nothing dramatic. There was also a very slight difference in the print color, with the Photoshop-profiled one being somewhat more neutral in tone than the printer-profiled one, which was a tad warmer.


While tonal values on prints are not always literally translated to repro, the paper can produce a deep black, although it certainly does not have the snap found in glossy or Vellin surfaces. It's more like a "buff" black look, akin to charcoal or chalk pastel. Copyright:  George Schaub

One control you might want to test is found in the small checkboxes under the preview in Photoshop, particularly “Match Print Color.” Click it on and off to see what best matches the image you have loaded. In some cases it can be quite noticeable, and assuming your setup is profiled it will give you a better visual idea of what will result. In some cases it can help with “un-muddying” darker values and resulted in a crisper, though not deep black, but again test this, as it seems to be image dependent.

Image Intent
This brings up matching image with idea and result with intent. This is a paper that renders values in a unique way, one that you could describe as “spiritual.” It’s not a matter of sharpness, but of mood. I would not choose this paper for color-rich or deep black value images, which I usually print to bring out the “snap.” That’s why my first instinct was working with those IR images, which have unique mid-range and especially highlight values. In that sense it is a paper designed for select, not general printing.


Bamboo is versatile enough to allow you to create a wide range of expression. This photo was made with a Lensbaby auxiliary lens and has a naturally soft "aura." I dropped the saturation to match the mood and came up with a look and feel that was quite different from any print I had ever made from this image. Copyright George Schaub

This became apparent when I switched from IR to landscapes with high contrast values, which I usually print on a Vellin or smooth rag surface. The blacks are there in the Bamboo stock, but have a feeling of buff rather than hard rendition. I printed some images deep with very slightly suppressed highlights, and found that every nuance came through in both highlights and mid-tones. In any case it’s a unique look, one that creates an entirely different impression than other papers.

(One tip is to give the print time to dry down before you make any quick adjustments. The print sets after an hour or so, although you probably should give it more time before you rush back to change the contrast or value settings, especially in dark tonal areas.)

One option perhaps worthy of exploration is making copy prints from old images. I copied this carte de visite from the nineteenth century and tried it out and got a nice rendition of values that, combined with the print surface, gave it a true look and feel.

Conclusion
Overall, I always welcome new papers to add to my creative gamut, and given the right image and processing, Hahnemuehle’s Bamboo 290 gsm will hold a special place in my paper stock cabinet when it comes to nature, landscape and even portraiture. While monochrome printers should certainly consider checking it out, those trying it with color images of a certain mood and style will also find new expressive avenues to explore.


1.      













: Hemp is a bright white matt paper with a slight textural surface, ideal for color work; and Agave has a more textural surface with a bright white base. All the papers are 290gsm and none use optical brighteners.

Wednesday, November 16, 2016

Canson Baryta Prestige 340gsm: Paper Test and Review


 Canson’s new Baryta Prestige is a 340 gsm inkjet paper comprised of acid-free alpha-cellulose and cotton white paper with a true Barium sulphate (“baryta”) coating. The baryta nomenclature tags it as having the look and feel of silver halide prints that will appeal to those who know what that entails: for those who don’t it is a durable paper that brings a feeling of richness and depth not only to tonal values and hues but to the surface and weight of the paper itself. Inks seem to blend in with the surface rather than sit on top, a very pleasing look.

It is a “smooth gloss” paper, which means that it has the look and sharpness of traditional glossy paper while lacking the distracting sheen of a “hard” surface gloss. For those who have worked in a darkroom that’s like double-weight glossy dried matte. It has a weight and durability that while defending the sheet from handling problems does not prevent the user from using virtually every photo inkjet printer (not all-in-ones) out today.

I tested Baryta Prestige using a Canon PRO-1000 and Epson SureColor P800, thermal and piezoelectric inkjet printers respectively. I worked with three images: one with bold color, one a mixture of monochrome and color areas, and one “straight” black and white.

Test Results
Both printers handle up to 300gsm weight papers through the normal single-sheet feed paths, but being heavier weight I loaded the paper using the Epson front-feed and Canon back/manual feed trays. While I would advise flexing the paper to help it maintain flatness with the Epson, the Canon manual tray path passed the paper through with no problem. (There was no problem with the Epson either; it just seemed to be less than flat when feeding it so I flexed it prior to aligning it with the guides and it passed through with no skewing whatsoever.) 

I processed the images in Adobe Photoshop CC 2015.5 on a MacBook Pro that is calibrated to my Cinema Display. I downloaded the Canson ICC profiles (www.canson-infinity.com/en/icc-profiles) and worked with Photoshop Managed Color/Perceptual Intent on two color images and black and white modes (printer controlled color in the Epson and the Canon black and white print checkoff in the driver). I made no adjustments to the processed image between printers.  The paper profile and surface called for PK (Photo Black) ink. If you have matte black set up in the Epson you have to wait a bit while it switches to Photo Black; the Canon uses two separate feeds for PK and PM inks so no swapping time is required.

Overall both printers delivered very good results. Colors were rich and true and highlight texture is nuanced. The paper surface has a very slight stipple (unlike a hard gloss) and there is no noticeable gloss differential. The weight of the paper is such that mounting and matting will present no problems; overall it has a substantial and durable feel.

Canson ICC profile, Photoshop CC 2015.5, Madrid Wall Composite copyright George Schaub

In the color image, the Canon delivered a cleaner (somewhat brighter) yellow and a slightly more differentiated red.  Both printers yielded a rich D-Max (deep black) with nice tonal gradation from dark to light gray. Bright whites were clean with very subtle highlight values down from bright to soft white. Blues and cyans seem richer on the Epson print. These comparatives are based on side-by-side prints: taken alone each is very good and would be more than pleasing to the eye.

Canson ICC profile, Photoshop CC 2015.5, Composite 2 copyright George Schaub

I chose a composite graphic with both grayscale and subtle color touches to check how the Canon and Epson would handle the black and white values without using the monochrome checkoff option in their drivers. The dark tonal areas of the monochrome values in the image were reproduced with a rich and even startling depth; highlights maintained their starkness without loss of textural nuance. If anything, the SureColor P800 yielded richer reds and subtler blues, a result that was apparent in the full color image print as well.


I chose a monochrome image that displays a very wide gamut of values, from creamy and textural whites through a range of grays to deep black. I used the “black and white” checkoff in the Canon driver and Epson’s Advanced Black and White mode. Both prints showed a depth and tonal separation that was very pleasing, with the Epson printing out a tad darker overall. I would not hesitate to use this paper for any of my monochrome images.

Conclusions and Recommendations
Now that we have printers that can yield excellent results, printmakers owe it to themselves to work with inkjet papers that can bring out the most vivid and vital tonal values and hues of the image itself. Working with the ICC profiles and, with monochrome images and settings in the respective printer drivers, Canson’s Baryta Prestige showed itself to be an excellent partner to these two quality inkjet printers. New to the market as of fall, 2016, it can take its place among the thoroughbred class of fine art papers that has the weight, surface, optical density, wide color gamut and archival characteristics that will allow you to make prints that you will be proud to display.

Contact, size and pricing: www.canson-infinity.com/en